Review of the Oasis of the Seas
We departed from Fort Laurderdale, it was very quick to get on board. We arrived at about noon. When we got on the person greeting us suggested we not go to the windjammer for lunch because it would be too crowded so he suggested a different venue. We ignored his suggestion and went to the windjammer and I am glad we did, we found a seat without any problem. The food was the best food in the windjammer for the whole cruise! From that point on, I was not impressed with the windjammer food. The selection was small and it didn’t taste that great. There was some Asian cuisine that my husband liked but overall the windjammer was good. Breakfast was good with a typical variety. We never tried dinner there. We rarely had trouble finding seats. It might have been crowded and we would have search the whole place for a table and a couple of times, we grabbed a dirty table and waited for someone to clean it. Overall, I give the windjammer a C.
By the time we finished our lunch that first day, we went to our cabin. That was a nice surprise. The cabins were bigger than we have had in the past. We also got an outside cabin and it had a HUGE window, my kids (even the 17 year old) could lie in the window. We had one room with 2 beds pushed together and a sofa too! Our cabin connected to our kids cabin which had 2 beds and a sleeper sofa. It would have been better to have had 2 upper bunks rather than the sleeper sofa and I didn’t realize this wasn’t the case when I booked the cruise. So, if you are used to quads = 2 upper bunks like us, play close attention because many are sleeper sofas which mean that everyone won’t get their own beds. My kids weren’t happy about sleeping together. We won’t do a sleeper sofa again. The rooms also come with a large flat screen TV that you can check your sea pass account by yourself at any time, it also shows when your shows are, let’s you make reservations, sign waivers for all sport activities, and more. You also get a ton of free movies and regular TV. Our cabin was on deck 3. I really liked this deck, it was convenient to everything, very quiet, more affordable, and the rooms were the same size as the more expensive cabins, we just had the big window instead of the balcony and at $400 + savings, I would stick to deck 3.
On Deck 3, you are right at deck to get off the ship, you are right at the dining hall, and Opus Theater is right there too. The Casino is only 1 deck up and the promenade is only 2 decks up. The ships elevators are moved closer to the middle so it is not a long walk to get anywhere. You don’t feel lost and even young kids, 9+ could find there way around on their own. There are TV screens around the ship to direct you but after the first day, you learn the ship and don’t really need them. It was one of the easiest ships to get around on.
The shows on board were great! Hairspray, the broadway musical was phenomenal. It was very funny and very well done. I would recommend it for ages 6 and up. We also saw Learn To Fly, this involved a lot of acrobatic moves, some singing (slow songs that were not that interesting), and people flying over your head. It was a very good show. We didn’t go to the ice skating show but my mother and step father took my daughter and they liked it. We saw the Oasis of the Dreams, it is a mix of diving, gymnastics, and synchronized swimming. I didn’t care much for the swimming. They didn’t choreograph it very well. The diving was nice, like the Olympics. The gymnastics was the best part of the show. Overall, this was my least favorite show, but was still good. The comedy show was an adults only show. The first act was very clean and I wish my kids could have seen it. The second act was 50/50. Both were very good. Although, I think they switch out performers for both the comedy club and the Headliner show- so your mileage may vary. Speaking, of the Headliner show, we got to see Beatle Mania. Basically, it was like going to a Beatles concert, it was excellent. Again, they switch these around, so the Beatle Mania group may or may not be there for future cruises.
Another show we saw was the comedy improv show on the last night, no tickets were needed. This was very funny and I highly recommend it. Sit up front if you want to participate and maybe get on stage to perform with the actors. Make sure you are comfortable with doing improv in front of a large audience in you volunteer. We also did a comedy improv workshop with some of the actors from Hairspray. This was a fun activity, especially to bring kids age 9+ to unless they are super shy.
There were lots of activities to do but be prepared to wait a long time. I did the zip line on the day right after we got on board, this the best time to use the flow riders and zip line. You will need to sign some waivers over by the zip line first. You also need sneakers or socks and they will provide shoes. It isn’t scary at all. I get scared of lots of things but I wasn’t afraid of this. As for the rest of the things, ice skating isn’t open on shore days and you have to get in line 30 minutes before they open (which we didn’t know so we never got to do this) if you want a spot. The rink is small and they only let a small number of people on. Other activities that I wanted to with my kids were all scheduled to conflict with early dinner, this was very frustrating as I would think most families would pick early dinner. They did the parade at 5:30 on formal night when that is the time to get pictures taken! There wasn’t too much to do if you chose not to go into port, which we didn’t do every day. There were large periods of time when there was nothing fun to do. They need more activities. They also schedule fun things very late and although I stayed up to 2:00 am a couple times to do some stuff, I was tired toward the end of the week and an 11:30 activity was just too late, I wish they would make them earlier so all can enjoy them, not just the night owls. Then, they would schedule dancing lessons at 10:00am, who is ready to dance at 10:00am, when they just stayed up until 2:00 am to do the other activities? They need reexamine their whole schedule. Overall, they get a C- for activities.
Now for the dining room. We had a great wait staff. Most RCCL cruises we have been on, we have had great waiters (waiters always tend to be better than the waitresses overall…). A couple of cruises, we got stuck with just average ones and that has been disappointing but our waiters on this cruise were great. We had high expectations for the food – after all, this was the Oasis of the Seas, the most expensive and biggest ship – we should get a pretty exciting menu! NOT… the menu is the same menu as the cheapest and smallest (Monarch of the Seas) RCCL ship. We were expecting some variety and something a little better. Not that the food is bad, it is good – we just thought we would get something a little more than we get when we pay $200 to go on the Monarch. The menu was the same – the food very good – not amazing, not bad – I would give it a B+ / A-.
The other food venues: Johnny Rockets is free for breakfast. We tried it once. I thought since it was cooked to order, it would taste better. It didn’t. My pancakes still were hard around the edges… how do they make that happen?? They lack breakfast drinks – I hope you like OJ, it is all they got for you! My son paid to have lunch at Johnny Rockets once, he said it wasn’t great. I bought milkshakes there and they were below average. So I give Johnny Rockets a thumbs down – C-. The Park Cafe is in the beautiful Central Park, it is really nice. It has great sandwiches and salads. We ate there quite a bit. It was always easy to get in and get food quick and had good hours. Also, it was nice to eat in Central Park. I give Park Cafe an A-. The donut shop on the boardwalk serves free donuts. All the donuts are plain donuts with frosted tops of various tops – passion fruit, strawberry, chocolate, lime, etc. They were terrible in my opinion. I LOVE donuts but I ate 1 donut and didn’t finish it. The bottoms tasted stale. The only thing good was to eat the chocolate off the top. :-) I was not alone in not liking the donuts. They need to make other types of donuts, like cake donuts or something – and the toppings like passion fruit, ick! They were pretty but that’s it. Donut shop: D. The pizza place: Sorrentos was very popular. They served pizza. The pizza was good, not great, but good. I wished they served other things there like Carnival does but all you get is pizza. My kids ate there a lot. I would give it a B. We never ate at the Solarium so I can’t rate that. As for the pay for you dinner restaurants, we considered doing that one night and went to all the places and read the menus. The only one that looked okay was the Italian place. My mother did eat there and really liked it. We found that the things that appealed to me on that menu were actually also being served in the dining room (for free) that night, so we just went there and that is what I ordered (which was the same thing my mother got at the Italian place, although she got a lot of other types of food with it, she said it was family style.) In general, I don’t do pay for dinner as I like the food in the dining hall and don’t see the point in paying for dinner when I don’t have to. The other restaurants did not have anything that appealed to me or had things that we could still get in the dining hall. I also tried the cupcake shop. The cupcakes look soooo good, but don’t be fooled – they are nasty! The frosting is yummy but I don’t know what they make their cake from, I tried two different ones and my daughter tried one – and none of them were good. They cost $2.75 per cupcake. I give it a D.
The best part of the ship was how beautiful it was. I loved the different areas: Central Park, Boardwalk, Solarium, Promenade. It is really beautiful ship. The shops are lacking, which is a shame given they have the space. However, I give the ship and it’s layout an A.
The bars – the nightclubs were TINY, for such a big ship, why they couldn’t devote more space to the nightclubs is beyond me! The dance floors are really small and one bar has an upstairs and downstairs which is impossible if you want to dance and are forced to sit upstairs. The music played was not our cup of tea, all rap stuff that constantly changed – never the same song through until the end. We found it hard to dance to, we didn’t stay long. The casino was also terrible. They had 1 set of tables marked as $5 tables that were so packed you couldn’t play and the other table was so high that no one played there and it was empty, so instead of having 2 tables at $5 that were full, they lost customers and people didn’t get to play. Sometimes we had to play craps on the smoking side because the craps table on the nonsmoking side was too packed and we wanted to play craps but often that was empty and who wants to play craps alone, so we just didn’t play. Very frustrating.
The worst thing for me was the lack of drinkable beverages! Carnival has lemonade and ice tea available to their guests 24 hours. RCCL has nothing! If you went to Sorrentos, you got water – with NO ICE (I hate not having ice with my water). In the windjammer there was flavored water – no lemonade. The only place I could get lemonade was in the dining room at dinner. And if it wasn’t meal time, there just seemed to be no options for fluids except water. Breakfast, all you could get was OJ or apple juice (and coffee of course, which I don’t drink). It was terrible, I had to drink so much soda on the cruise because I had no other option and I don’t want to be drinking soda. On Carnival, I always have ice tea or lemonade – even at 2 am! From now on, I will bring lemonade powder with me to mix with water on RCCL cruises but so many things about RCCL makes me prefer Carnival now. I used to like RCCL better but they have made some really poor decisions.
Cost for what you get: Would I pay the premium to go on the Oasis of the Seas again? No! It was not worth it. I would much prefer a Carnival cruise over an Oasis of the Seas cruise any day. The only 2 things about the cruise that really stood out to me where Hairspray, the “neighborhood” concept (Central Park, Boardwalk), and the nice cabins (minus the sofa bed idea). But none of that is worth the negatives and the cost.
Overall rating of the cruise as compared to other cruises: C.
What could RCCL do to improve the Oasis of the Seas?
1. Fix their scheduling: don’t schedule family activities right before or during early seating dinner, don’t do your parade on formal night when people are getting pictures done, have more activities, don’t schedule everything so late and so early – more stuff during the middle of the day, we had nothing to do during the middle of day and couldn’t do stuff we wanted because it was too early, too late, or conflicted with dinner.
2. Have lemonade and/or ice tea available 24 hours in multiple locations for people to access. Also keep your ice cream open 24 hours (they closed their ice cream, I don’t know how many times on Carnival, I saw people getting ice cream at 2:00 am…. the best time to have a small snack!)
3. Improve variety of food in Windjammer, variety of donuts, improve quality of food (donuts, cupcakes, even Windjammer food).
4. Skip the sofa beds, put in upper bunks for quads, no one wants to share a bed – make sofa bed rooms – triples, not quads!
5. Have comedy shows for the kids, have more comedy shows for adults to attend
Well, I hope this review helps some… maybe RCCL will read it… ha!